?

Log in

Romani on House MD - Romany Women

> Recent Entries
> Archive
> Friends
> Profile

April 20th, 2008


Previous Entry Share Next Entry
fuli_tschai
09:02 pm - Romani on House MD


Several weeks ago, there was an episode of House MD that deals with a young patient and his Romani family.

Heres the recap from the FOX webpage. The portions that relate to the family are in bold.


Needle in a Haystack
Aired 2/06/07
"A sixteen year-old named Stevie is making out with his girlfriend Leah in a car when he has a hard time breathing. He turns blue.

House takes his car into work because of the weather, but when he pulls into the hospital lot he finds that the handicapped parking space closest to the building is already occupied. There is a sign over the space that reads "J. Whitner, MD." House has been assigned a more distant space than he had before, and Whitner has his old spot.

Foreman approaches House about Stevie's case, but House is more interested in the new parking situation and the identity of J. Whitner. Cameron explains that Dr. Whitner is a new female researcher confined to a wheelchair. Foreman tries to get him focused on the case, pointing out that Stevie suffered respiratory arrest with no history and that his ER work-up showed a bloody pleural effusion. That last part finally grabs House's attention. House suggests a blood leak and orders a veinogram.

House tracks down Dr. Whitner in the research lab. Since her wheelchair is motorized, he figures there must be some parking mix up because he has to walk while she only needs to push a joystick. Whitner points out that it's hard for cars to see her so the parking lot is dangerous. She won't be giving the spot back.

As Stevie struggles with breathing and chest pains, Foreman is unable to track down the boy's parents to sign consent forms. Leah offers to have her parents sign, but that's not legally viable. Stevie claims his parents are probably at a conference and had to shut off their cell phones. Suddenly, his oxygen stats plummet. Foreman has no choice but to perform the veinogram now. He will deal with the fallout later.

As Foreman begins the procedure, Stevie notices a diffusion pattern on the monitor and declares that it is Graham's law. He figures the leak has to be in his pulmonary veins in order to get into his lungs. Impressed, Foreman asks if he is studying this in high school. Stevie claims to read things on his own, and then he quickly changes the subject. When nothing shows up on the test, Stevie wonders how he can have a bloody effusion without any bleeding.

Cameron and Chase go to Stevie's home to look for drug use. The first thing they find is rotting food in the kitchen. Chase sees two people having sex in one of the bedrooms. The couple has no idea who Stevie is.

The doctors confront Stevie about the address he supplied. He tries to cover, but they know he's lying. Leah finally admits that Stevie is Romani, which is a gypsy. Stevie explains that the doctors cannot go to his home because their mere presence will spiritually pollute it and his parents treat that very seriously. He promises to tell them anything they need to know as long as they don't go where he lives. His family earns its living by buying and selling anything they can. Stevie was just in Chicago with his father last week on such a venture.

House confronts Cuddy about the parking issue and the debate quickly devolves into a bet. Cuddy predicts that House couldn't last one week in a wheelchair. He accepts the challenge. The team spots House rolling around the lobby and they update him on the case. Stevie's veinogram showed no leakage, and none in the lymphatics. House, adamant that blood outside the circulatory system could only come from a leak, advises his charges to stop trusting Stevie's claims and find some answers on their own. Either that, or they can thin out his blood for another veinogram.

Taking matters into their own hands, Cameron and Foreman perform an arteriogram first. Foreman suspects deep vein thrombosis from Stevie's recent long drive to and from Chicago. Cameron begins inserting a tube into a leg artery and Stevie cries out with stomach pain. The dye Cameron injected is entering Stevie's liver but not leaving it. The liver is completely blocked.

The team reconvenes with House, who sticks with his leak theory. Figuring a mass could be poking holes in Stevie's arteries, House asks for a CT, an MRI, a sputum and an ACE level. Then he wheels off. Stevie, who's beginning to turn yellow, enters the MRI. Foreman laments that Stevie's intelligence is being wasted by parents who are forcing him to sell scrap material. The doctors think they've spotted a granuloma on the MRI just as Stevie's parents barge into the room.

Foreman tracks down House in the parking lot and breaks the news about the granuloma. They now know it's Wegener's. House, encouraged by the development, tells Foreman that a liver biopsy will take too long. They need to start treatment with cyclophosphamide before things get worse. House then lifts himself from the wheelchair to his car, asking Foreman for help folding up the wheelchair. Foreman refuses and walks back into the hospital.

Foreman checks up on Stevie and notices that the parents Franklin and Constance have taken over the room, providing him with their clothing, their blankets and their food. Foreman chafes, noting that the hospital needs to control the environment in order to know if the tests are working. Stevie's parents argue that their son's life is simply out of balance and they're helping to restore it.

Later, Foreman returns for another checkup and finds Franklin and Constance shouting at Leah to get out of the room. They blame her for Stevie's troubles. Stevie begins to moan in agony. When Foreman pulls back the blankets, a large bloodstain covers Stevie's groin.


The team reports to House that the treatment for Wegenger's caused a massive hemorrhage in Stevie's bladder. House thinks that's good, which baffles his team. Everything else is ruled out. They have the correct diagnosis but the wrong treatment. They need to change the immune system, and House mentions an experimental drug named FT-28. Stevie's immune system is attacking his blood vessels. They can change his immune system so that the drug doesn't react to the blood vessels but works everywhere else. Cameron, ever mindful, points out that FT-28 isn't FDA approved. It has, however, worked for Crohn's disease. House suggests that they say Stevie has Crohn's so that they can administer the drug.

Franklin and Constance flatly refuse to allow the hospital to experiment on their son. Franklin mentions the medical experiments at Auschwitz and Foreman counters with the Tuskegee experiments. With no gains made in the argument, Foreman consults with House who advises him to become a better salesman. He must somehow earn the family's trust.

Stevie's extended family is now in the patient room and there's a festive, happy air. Foreman hooks up a new IV and then asks the family to give them some privacy so he can change the bandages around Stevie's groin. When the room is emptied, Foreman explains to Stevie that the doctors want to alter his treatment but that his parents won't let them. Stevie realizes that their resorting to experimental treatment means they must be out of answers. How can he trust Foreman? Foreman gives him the medicine and instructs him not tell his parents. If they find out, then Foreman will lose his license. That's how he knows he can be trusted. Stevie begins writhing in agony from intense pain.


A surgeon removes Stevie's ruptured spleen and gives it to Foreman to perform a biopsy for Wegener's. House watches from the observation deck in his wheelchair. He doesn't spot anything out of the ordinary or granulomas. House asks them to run Stevie's bowel, but the surgeon begins closing him up. House needs to get downstairs quickly, but he also needs to win his bet. The elevator is taking too long, so House bounces his wheelchair down the stairs and barges into the OR, insisting that a granuloma is indeed present. House stands up and sticks his gloved hands into Stevie's body to feel the small intestine for granuloma. The surgical team immediately stops working in fear of a lawsuit. House reaches the end of the small intestine and finds nothing. There is no granuloma. Stevie's parents were right.

House and his team head back to the drawing board. Still suspecting the bowel, House orders a colonoscopy. They will need to move fast because Stevie is in the ICU, which has limited visiting privileges. The doctors must get to Stevie before the family cuts off their access. The colonoscopy, like everything else, comes out normal. Suddenly, Foreman spots a toothpick. Stevie chews on them like his father does. He must have accidentally swallowed one. During his make-out session, an awkward movement could've pushed the toothpick through the colon wall and into the lung. From there, it traveled to the liver, then the kidney, then the spleen.

Franklin processes this news, then immediately blames Leah. If she wasn't kissing Stevie, this never would have happened. Leah blames Franklin for passing such a disgusting habit on to his son. Foreman visits with Stevie and says he will be fine in a few days. Foreman then mentions that the hospital lab has a paid internship which is usually given to a university student. He promises to arrange an interview for him. Stevie thanks him but passes on the offer. Foreman implores him to put his mind to use, but Stevie notes that Foreman, Cameron and Chase are all single and alone. Stevie wants a family.

House goes to reclaim his parking spot from Cuddy, but she knows that he stood up in the operating room. He lost the bet. House accuses Cuddy of never planning on giving him the space. That would explain why Dr. Whitner wasn't concerned about losing her parking when House confronted her earlier in the week. House asks Cuddy if she feels even a little bit guilty about her scheme.

That night, as he leaves the hospital, House sees a maintenance worker putting his name back on the spot closest to the building."



I'm trying to absorb it, since I didn't actually get to see this episode, but these are a few things, (good and bad) that come to mind:

The doctors confront Stevie about the address he supplied. Leah finally admits that Stevie is Romani, which is a gypsy. Stevie explains that the doctors cannot go to his home because their mere presence will spiritually pollute it and his parents treat that very seriously.

Depending on how traditional the family is, this could or could not be accurate. I think, at least in my own family and other Romani families/people I've met, we don't do things much differently, (if at all) from anyone else, so to me it seems a bit far fetched, particularly the following:

Stevie's parents argue that their son's life is simply out of balance and they're helping to restore it.

This, to me, is where the racial stereotyping comes in, as if all Romani people are new-age hippies. Not that I have anything against hippies, mind you, but it just doesn't tend to be the case 90% of the time. I don't know a single American Romani (or certainly Romanies anywhere else in the world) who would refuse proper medical care for themselves or a family member if their life was in danger - and I can't imagine even very traditional Romanies, while they may not be trusting, saying something like that. The occupation of the parents bothers me a bit, too, because there are plenty of Romani people in more conventional occupations (doctors, nurses, lawyers, teachers, etc.) so I see that as another example of how mainstream society (in the United States, at least) perceives the word 'gypsy' (not capitalized here because it seems to have been used more as a term to describe their lifestyle than their ethnicity - "oh, they're gypsies? well, they must not have any proper means of living, probably selling junk by the side of the road", etc..) so, not too pleased with those things. I also don't care for how the family is portrayed as completely ignorant to modern medicine, but I am impressed that the Holocaust referrence was used, only because it means Romani people are finally getting some widespread recognition when it comes to that subject. My hope is that one or more of the many watchers of the show Google'd 'gypsies' and 'holocaust' and educated themselves on our past as a people, thereby wiping out the 'Esmerelda/Disney' image and replacing it with a more accurate one. We kind of have to sneak that stuff in where we can, eh?

The parents being portrayed as overbearing and hostile doesn't strike me as having anything to do with their race, as this seems to be the case with all the parents/spouses/sisters/brothers/cousins, etc on the show. They never cooperate with House and his team or trust him (sometimes with good reason!) and that seems to be a major theme in the show from the beginning, so no shocker there.

I do like the part where the character is offered an internship, (recognizing, for anyone who had doubt or 'needed to see it on tv first' to believe it, that Gypsies can read and write and are just as intelligent and capable as anyone else,) and I also like the fact that he turns it down. Maybe I'm a sap, but him pointing out that everyone else is alone and that's not what he wants for his life is both very perceptive and heartwarming at the same time.. but maybe that's just me :)

All in all, it could have been so much worse in terms of stereotyping us, or making us look like a joke. Yes, they got some things wrong, but they got some things right, too. I'm not terribly offended by the inaccurate parts.. at least we weren't portrayed as tossing glitter around and consulting our crystal balls! I tend not to be as bothered by the 'American version' of the stereotype as I am the European one, where we're not even considered human in some places. And then, in some ways, it makes the notion that we're a fictional character all that much worse because of the suffering and discrimination that is going on in other places. It's nice to be recognized, but it seems people still aren't quite clear on what 'we' are. More than sub-human, less than magical. Yep, that about covers it ;)

Thoughts?



(Leave a comment)


> Go to Top
LiveJournal.com